Leave a Message

By providing your contact information to Staff Homes, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Staff Homes's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you expressly consent to receive marketing or promotional real estate communication from Staff Homes in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase of any goods or services. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Staff Homes at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe. SMS text messaging is subject to our Terms of Use.

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

About Paul Staff

Paul Staff Indianapolis, IN Real Estate Agent Headshot

Agent Details

Meet Paul

I'm Paul Staff, REALTOR® and co-founder of Staff Homes Real Estate. My love for Indianapolis goes back more than 40 years — long before I moved here. I spent years traveling to this city to visit my wife's family, watching it grow and change with every visit. When we finally moved here in 2015, it felt less like starting over and more like coming home to a place I'd already fallen for.
 
Before real estate, I spent 20 years as VP of Sales at Speedo and went on to serve as VP of Sales at Adidas — work that shaped how I think about strategy, negotiation, and building lasting relationships. I brought all of that into real estate when I transitioned into the business in 2020. Since then, I've sold over 75 homes and more than $40 million in volume, with a focus on luxury properties and helping buyers and sellers navigate Indianapolis with confidence.
 
I believe the best real estate experiences are built on trust, and I work hard to earn that from every client. You get someone who is straightforward, honest about what I'd do in your position, and fully committed to your outcome from the first conversation to the final signature. Real estate done well is about relationships first — and that's how I approach every single transaction.
 
I work alongside my daughter Becca, and together we offer something most teams can't: deep local knowledge paired with fresh eyes, and two people who are completely invested in your outcome.
 
Outside of real estate, I love spending time in my backyard, grilling, and enjoying time with family — including four Shih Tzus who have very strong opinions about everything. Indianapolis continues to grow and evolve, and after more than 40 years of watching that happen, I still find it one of the most exciting things about living here.

Testimonials

Rachel C.

Rachel C.

This market is crazy, but Paul helped make our home-buying process so seamless. As first-time homebuyers, we had a lot of questions. He was always available to chat or meet with us when needed. We can’t thank him enough!
Read More
Buyer | Seller

Buyer | Seller

Paul's great. He feels like family and is a giant sweetheart. Not only that, but he's a great agent too! His help made getting all of our questions answered easy and made the process painless and smooth.
Read More
Paige D.

Paige D.

Paul was a great help in finding our first home. He was very timely in his responses, helped us learn to navigate and negotiate our way through the fierce housing market, and was always honest with us.
Read More
Buyer

Buyer

We absolutely loved working with Paul! Buying a house is usually a momentous task, but with him, it was a pleasurable experience. He was upfront about everything, got to know what we liked and disliked, and found lots of houses...
Read More
Jamie B.

Jamie B.

We loved working with Paul. We immediately felt at ease and knew that he had only our best interests in mind. Paul did not pressure us into making an offer, and he genuinely enjoys the process. I would recommend Paul to anyone ...
Read More
Christi C.

Christi C.

Paul was such a joy to work with. He always went above and beyond to make sure we found the right home. He helped us find the right lender and took the stress out of buying a house.
Read More
Buyer

Buyer

Paul helped me find my new home. While we were viewing over 50 homes, it was a great journey together. He knows the area and the people. If there was something he wasn't sure about, he would find the answer for you. It's true t...
Read More
Michael P.

Michael P.

Paul was extremely great to work with! He was very patient with us and super helpful since my wife and I were first-time homebuyers. My wife and I always knew that Paul had our best interests in mind and listened to everything ...
Read More
Miles J.

Miles J.

Paul teamed up with me to identify and purchase my first investment property. In what could have been one of the more complex seller-side deals imaginable, Paul worked with me through each setback and communicated effectively w...
Read More
Nicolas B.

Nicolas B.

Paul went above and beyond to help us buy our first home. He quickly understood what we were looking for and was able to work with our schedule to see as many houses as possible in a short period of time. He gave us insight int...
Read More
Buyer | Seller

Buyer | Seller

I highly recommend Paul Staff, a top-rated real estate professional based in Indianapolis. With his extensive knowledge of the local market, Paul is an excellent choice for anyone looking to buy or sell property in the Indianap...
Read More
Trisha N.

Trisha N.

Paul was outstanding in every aspect of my journey to find the right home. He had an unwavering resolve to find me the home of my dreams. He never stopped looking for exactly what I wanted. I truly mean he never stopped looking...
Read More
Buyer

Buyer

Paul did such an awesome job helping me find and buy a home! He was super responsive and insightful. I appreciated his patience with a first-time homebuyer. I am so grateful for all his help.
Read More
Melissa M.

Melissa M.

Paul was an incredible realtor. We can’t recommend him enough. He was so helpful and responsive throughout our home-buying process. He went above and beyond every step of the way.
Read More
Evan O.

Evan O.

I could not have been happier with my experience working with Paul. Throughout the entire process, Paul was very responsive and always willing to dig into the details and provide options. Without hesitation, I would recommend h...
Read More
Buyer

Buyer

We couldn't be happier with our experience working with Paul to purchase our first home. First and foremost, his main focus was making sure we found a home we loved, even if the process took time. Throughout the process, he was...
Read More
Evan F.

Evan F.

Paul is fantastic to work with. He is responsive, hardworking, and caring. I highly recommend working with him to find a new home. Paul worked tirelessly to make sure we had the opportunity to tour many houses and helped us fin...
Read More
Buyer

Buyer

As a first-time homebuyer, I couldn’t have asked for a better experience than working with Paul. From scheduling tours to writing the offer and guiding me through every next step, he went above and beyond to ensure a smooth and...
Read More

Let's Find Your Dream Home

Home Search

We've Lived Everywhere. This is Home.

We've relocated, started over, and found home ourselves. With local expertise and a relationship-first approach, we're here to help you find yours in Indianapolis.

Follow Us on Instagram